There are always shades of gray between black and white. And anyone who has delved deeply into the Bach genealogy will encounter them ... these shades of gray. There, too. It’s usually an entire branch of the family that claims to belong to the Bach family of musicians from Eisenach. Or at least to share common ancestors with Veit Bach. Of course, it’s never just individual people who claim to be family members. After all, this proof of relationship then always applies equally to their relatives as well ... from the grandfather to the cousin to the grandchild. For an outsider who is deeply immersed in researching – above all – the correct genealogy of this super composer, it’s a fascinating experience.1126.
A long-cherished treasure in my family that connects me to America. This document was one of the things that prompted us to search for connections between Johann Sebastian Bach and the United States. And after about nine hours of “Googling nonstop,” it first led us to Bach scholar Helga Brück. And finally to our hoped-for destination.1126.
Advertisement
60 Music Calendars, Bach Calendars, Composers Calendars and Many Bach Gifts.1126.
The Bach Drehkastl (... Bach Turning Box). To all Bach shops.
An incredible number of Bach gift ideas ... learn more here. You can visit the “Bach-Seal Shop” here: Just one click is all it takes.1126.
End of Advertisement
That wasn't more than what our family had regarded for over 50 years as “a lost treasure the size of a shoebox”. But if you finally know how to contextualize this legacy – that is, just a single sheet of paper – then it is – genealogically – of inestimable value.1126.
Peter Bach, Jr. – dressed as a Bavarian – two generations before I became interested in genealogy: Two generations of 25 years each make up the defined 50 years. At this age, most people interested in the subject begin researching their own family history. 1126.
Clues – Conjectures – Documents – Evidence ... A Journey Across Generations.1126.
Is your last name Bach, or are you related to the Bach family of musicians? Or do you at least suspect so? We can help. Thanks to the records that have been available for centuries ... and above all, based on the incredibly meticulous work of Bach scholars and authors such as Helmuth Karl Abendroth, Prof. Günther Kraft, Knut Kreuch, Kurt Hermann Frickel, Hermann Kock, Ragnhild Siegel, Helga Brück, and Karl Geiringer, we believe we have now compiled the most comprehensive, complete, and – above all – most correct genealogy of the Bach musical family.1126
The latest findings – and, of course, “new” Bachs, as some are being called today – are constantly reshaping Bach’s genealogy. “Compiled” ... does mean, however, that as of now, hardly any of this material had been prepared for publication. A project that took not just years, but – to achieve absolute perfection – certainly a decade and a half. This “job” is now – in the summer of 2025 – largely complete with the publication of all results for part 1. Namely, the completion of the optimization of the genealogy from the very first Bachs up to Veit Bach in Wechmar.1126.
Optimizing the family tree based on this Veit Bach from Wechmar will likely continue for the next 20 years. Soon, the complete family tree – as current as it is at that time – will also be available via Ancestry. So ... that’s the plan. Unfortunately, we may, can, and will only publish the most recent branches and family members within the family … and even then, only after receiving explicit approval from each individual “person concerned.” In this way, we respect data protection and the rights of individual family members, and we ensure their willingness to continue making sensitive information available for Bach scholarship ... more specifically, Bach genealogy.1126.
So what if you’re searching now? Two clues – or better yet, three clues, at least – should already point to your connection to the Bach family of musicians. For example, your grandfather’s research. Or a family tree that already exists and points in the direction of the composer. A piece of indication is an assumption or a clue that is verifiable in some way. However, the last name Bach alone – or even being from Thuringia, one of the Bach places, or one of the Bach cities – is not enough.1126.
If, however, a family connection to the musicians is possible, please feel free to contact us: Then we’ll walk part of your journey with you! Because in that case, we, too, are extremely interested in learning more about your background. There are still many “blank spots” on the genealogical map of the musicians’ family.1126.
In addition, we may be able to offer personal assistance based on our experience. Or perhaps we even share a common interest in asking Mr. Hoske for his help and financing it together. Of course ... at a special price, naturally. If we don’t respond to your email, that’s not our style. It just means our spam filter has “flagged” your message. In that case, simply send us a brief follow-up note by regular mail. We’re looking forward to your feedback. Or give us a call.1126.
Related to Johann Sebastian Bach ... Some Folks Are Part of the Game.1126
For a tiny group of people, the matter is clear, crystal clear ... they belong! They are clearly related to Johann Sebastian Bach. Very few are even grandchildren, of course, great-great-great-great-great-grandchildren, to be exact ... and genealogically accurate as well. A few more are descended from the musical founding father, Veit Bach. This is especially true of quite a few Bachs in the United States.1126.
For some Bachs and for some people with other last names, the dream of being able to prove a clear connection, however, never comes true ... at least not yet. That’s because they simply haven’t found the evidence that settles everything. Some haven’t found it because they haven’t seriously tried yet. Others still can’t find it, even though they’ve been searching for it for decades ... often into the second or third generation.1126.
But now let’s turn to the exciting third group that regularly “pops up”: on the internet, in Thuringia, or even in Leipzig, Germany. If you delve deeply into the subject of Bach genealogy – I mean, very deeply – you can gain some curious insights, even without numerous examples. 1126.
What characterizes this third group in the Bach genealogy? How can one recognize it? How does one arrive at this conclusion, and what are the implications?.1126.
First and foremost, the goal is to gain recognition as a researcher in the field of Bach genealogy ... recognition from institutions, scholars, professors, and the “circle of the true greats in the world of Bach”. These leading figures in Bach studies are based in Leipzig, Eisenach, and Stuttgart. However, we have also included – and continue to include – the recognized specialists in Bach genealogy to this day: Abendroth, Kreuch, Kraft, Frickel, Brück, Kock, Siegel, and Odrich. Even though only two of these specialists are still alive (... as of 2025). The strictly scientific standard is also my goal. To be on par with them – the individuals mentioned above – in their research must be the goal of the next generation of Bach genealogists. Since 2017, unfortunately, only Helmuth Karl Abendroth and, of course, the current mayor of Gotha, Knut Kreuch, are still alive. We had the pleasure of meeting Ms. Brück and Ms. Odrich and enjoyed working together on Bach genealogy. Unfortunately, we do not know whether Ragnhild Siegel is still alive.1126.
The Self-Fulfilling Prophecy ... An Extremely Strong Clue Invalidates Itself.1126.
Let’s take a trip to the stock market, to this gambling table, to a real casino, and into the world of business. It’s all about that “amazing method” for raking in fantastic profits ... whether through stocks, currencies, “systems,” or commodities on the stock market, or through gambling in general. It’s all about secret tips. Or about having found the ultimate system for the roulette table or the electronic trading floor. But there is no way – no method you can discover – to generate unlimited money on the stock market.1126.
It just doesn't work. Worse yet: Systems like this can't possibly work. To begin with, no one who thinks he has discovered a foolproof system actually publishes it. Why would he? Why would anyone want to let others in on it ... only to risk having to split the profits?!.1126.
Let’s assume a “system” has been discovered that apparently actually works at some point. So someone spreads the word. And you benefit from this word-of-mouth if you didn’t figure it out yourself ... but rather read about it. Then, in no time at all, more and more market participants will try to get rich using this model. Then, more and more market participants are also willing to “flog” this system for an ever-lower “selling price as knowledge.” Eventually, so many speculators, investors, and ordinary consumers are participating in this pyramid scheme that it can no longer work. By definition. The system self-terminates.1126.
Here’s an example: tulip bulbs. Someone considers them valuable. He also convinces others to buy them. Why? Because their value keeps rising. More and more people “jump on board.” At first, the price rises sharply. Then it skyrockets. Eventually, every conceivable participant joins the “musical chairs”. So there’s no one left to be the next “sucker.” The system can no longer function. The game is over. And what does all this have to do with Bach? A great deal. We return to a significant piece of indication that, for exactly the same reason, has “run its course” for us as Bach scholars … it simply doesn’t work anymore. Not for us! But it does for you!.1126.
This extremely important clue has lost its significance for our research ... but not for you. How does something like that happen? Since publishing this website, we’ve occasionally received inquiries using exactly this wording ... with a request for help. We’re happy to help. And we’re especially happy to help because we want to complete it ... the genealogy of Johann Sebastian Bach. So it’s a shared interest.1126.
But: We can’t tell right now (... any more) whether such a statement was simply “made up” to persuade us to support you. Or whether this information has actually been circulating in your family for decades. You ( ! ) know, after all, whether you just made that up. Just to take a shot in the dark and ask Bach on Bach. It might just be a hit.1126.
We ... don’t know, though! And that’s okay. Because we can only offer you help to help yourself anyway. That means, plain and simple: At first, a lot of the work falls on you. Namely, to investigate what we recommend. And that involves traveling, “digging,” searching, and researching. Only when more evidence suggests that Grandpa might have been right – because he could have been the joker in your family – can we really step in and help with energy, expertise, and additional experts.1126.
The Mystrious Third Category
It is only through year-long correspondence and through many attempts to get more information that we can find common ground when it comes to examining branches that, according to statements by individuals, belong to the Bach musician family: by others, usually specialists, Bach-genealogists and before But especially in Leipzig, where there is undoubtedly scientific competence for Bach research. However, it is also important that the elite in Bach's science in Leipzig is essentially exclusively concerned with the phenomenon of Johann Sebastian Bach and is shown to be rather less interested in the musician family. It is simple and simple to analyze the claim to belong to another branch of the Bach musician family, to strict scientific work ... and which makes trouble and is uncomfortable. The first commonality of three individuals known to us, which always include the father, grandavers and ancestors as well as relatives - but this is logical - is that they are not involved in the current official genealogy, that is, the standard works of Kraft, Brück , Frickel, Kock, or Siegel do not list these individuals, including their branches. This means that they could be either corresoponded and not appreciative. Or researched alone without the knowledge of the experts in Deutschland and no contact with Leipzig or Eisenach, although there was the most effective information available.
The second common feature of these three groups is that a person in the respective group has exquisitely studied this genealogy and postulates the affiliation. He or she is followed by other family members without examination, but are usually skeptical in the correspondence, that is, Of the affiliation is also uncompromisingly familiar within. This brings us to a strange third community, which is only recognizable by the long-term correspondence and study mentioned above. With all three persons, who communicate their belonging not yet recognized by the Bach Science and the Bach Genealogy, there was a correspondence lasting many months before writing this page. And this correspondence took a decidedly unusual course. In any case and not just with this one authoritative person, but with other members of this branch and in conversation with other Bach specialists on the side of the recognized research.
Advertisement
60 Music Calendars: Pipe Organ Calendars, Bach Calendars, Composers Calendars, and Many Bach Gifts, Plus Music Gifts.1126
In fact, the link below the next few pictures will most likely take you to the place with the widest selection of Bach gifts ... in a store. You get to the “Bach Seal Shop” here: Just one click is all it takes.1126.
Please support our Bach Mission … learn more here. Here again, you get to the “Bach-Seal Shop”: Just one click is all it takes.1126.
End of Advertisement
It is already an intensive effort on my part to reach the following conclusions. All contacts have in common that the soliciting of more genealogical source information for the own research led to a strange behavior. It is of the utmost importance that in this contact, even the most powerful approach was expressed on my part, that we were of a different opinion as to the belonging to the musician family. And in all three cases this could also be recapitulated internally and traced in the correspondence. Three correspondences were very peculiar. The author of this website also had to deal with Bach genealogy researchers, whose theories were not officially acknowledged, which also mutually oppose each other - but ultimately everything worked out to convince with their theory and their facts. The tendency was clearly extroverted. They wanted to convince. They granted full access to each date, to each original, to each source. This is not the case with the three branches mentioned above. They live in the USA, Belgium and Poland. Explicitly, it is a second US branch, not the descendants of Reinhold Bach. And again, because it becomes concrete here: we, my wife and I, wish nothing more than to be able to assign a new branch by means of outstanding, scientific work of Bach's genealogy. This is essential to criticize.
f one wants to build a familial connection with the researching individuals and minds of these three branches, to appreciate them as researchers or to exchange data, then one thing is common to them. No original copy will be issued as a copy. And any contact that takes place from a certain level below superficiality is rejected. This leads, of course, to curious situations, which consist in not answering the most hearty letters by mail and at the same time by mail. Admittedly, on the grounds that you were sick and the wife too. But the son, who is definitely not so ill, also does not respond to requests at the same time. Even kinship requests to contact us are due to disabling. Only with a few contacts does one notice a pressing premise. On a telephone call one can not see a repetitive reaction. And only with a conversation partner can one find no parallelism between two processes (... actually logical).
There Actually One Bach Threatens to Sue Another Bach?
In the USA - completely deviated from Bach's research, and the flora and fauna on an island in the Pacific - unaffected, there is another brook branch. The story of the genealogist of this group of Bachs – her life was a psychological human catastrophe – is that for many decades there was no interest or approach to connect with Leipzig. And also not with the recognized Bach genealogy. Nevertheless, we succeeded in locating this stream branch over the course of hundreds of hours of research and with Ancestry the ancestral Internet portal. To this branch there is a book, which publishes the results of three generations of researchers. It is striking that the first two generations worked very meticulously and scientifically. This discovery of this branch meant, however, for the author of this website to now bring such a statement into agreement with the undisputed Bach genealogy. If you read here, you know that with my homepage there are possibilities to market this Bach book perfectly. And that was what the author offered. Free of charge, without hinds. Just because the find was exciting. Here a first precaution of the mentioned genealogist occurred. This response was dramatically intensified when we asked for copies of originals in which we wanted to comprehend the authenticity, self-examination, since it was no less than a description of Bach's genealogy. The contact cooled suddenly and dramatically. By pure coincidence later a different connection to a member from this branch arose later, this branch now "only" the name Bach or belongs it just also to the musician family. A planned trip to Germany was quickly re-planned, and we spent three wonderful days together in "Bach Country", as we call Thuringia. I asked this American brook to get in touch with his cousin, and, after we could convince him and his wife, not to do anything wrong, so to speak, as "Amricans among themselves". A two-and-a-half-hour telephone call was very harmonious. A second was the chaos, which was the sad depression of a lawsuit. The background is unimportant for this chapter of the story. It was all about achieving a harmonious second approach. Of course, we were all the more interested in the scientific aspects, and there were no less than eight curiosities, which in themselves are disagreeable.
The Curiosity
We are very convinced that even all three families are new, so far undiscovered branches of the musician family from Thuringia. But without scientific investigation, all three ... defacto are not. Actually, our common interest is so much the same as it is more ... simply can not. All three genealogists of all three branches would have to be very pleased that they were offered professional and free help. After all, by experts who have compiled the most recent, most comprehensive and correct Bach genealogy on earth ... on the basis of acknowledged Bach researchers and their work. Thus their behavior can only allow one conclusion: here, on the other side and on the other side of the Atlantic, "brick". For concern that specialists find the diffraction. The diffraction? We assume that belonging to the Bach family of all three branches is actually correct. However, a conclusive evidence is still lacking. And now, under all circumstances, one tries to prevent third parties from finding in the documents that a connection to Johann Sebastian Bach and his family does not exist. And so the curiosity arises that, by simply hiding the so important foundations and original documents on which the affiliation is formulated, clarification is not avoided but the worst case scenario is created for these researchers: the proof of non-belonging, because In the case of doubt, the diffraction is then one when one discovers where the hypothesis of the bonding member is suspected. This makes a diffraction intentional and what that is, I would not like to formulate here. As in customs, the principle of inversion applies in genealogy. We do not have to prove that a branch is not part of the musician family of Johann Sebastian Bach, but the one who has to assert that it is so. And this proof is not only not provided, but the access to the clarification is actively hidden. However:
In or Out ... It's That Simple!
For the author of this homepage and his wife, who pursues the genealogy decisively, sustainably and with enthusiasm, only one fact counts: it must be provable. Everything must be understandable. It must be right. Any doubtful classification of branches of the musician family of Johann Sebastian Bach beyond the acknowledged ones must also be publicly comprehensible and to be examined today - from outside, from the scientists in Leipzig and from their own relatives. If this is not possible, then we are sorry, and we are in agreement with all scientists around the world: anyone who deliberately withdraws from genealogy in a scientific setting – is "outside". If you are not listed here in the future, you simply do not belong to the musician family of Veit Bach and Johann Sebastian Bach – with scientific support.
How do you recognize diffraction? First of all, that inconsistencies are published in accessible areas. If, for example, an object is inherited, which later supports the essential statement, and this object is not assigned to the deceased with a probability of 99% because the biography simply proves the opposite. And if the signature of a will is ordained as authentic even though the original document has no signature. Then, if you bend once, do so a second time and a third time. And when you add 1 + 1 in a connection, you can see connections that remain completely hidden to all others.
Advertisement
60 Music Calendars, Composers Calendars and Bach Calendars.1126.
Bach calendars, pipe organ calendars, composers calendars, and music calendars. Three sizes. This year and next year. EU and US style. To the shop.1126.
Peter Bach Jr. already shared things early in life. Back then it was his ice cream, today it's much exciting stuff about Johann Sebastian Bach.
However, if a relationship with the composer is imaginable, we would love if you contact us. Then we share a portion of your way through the past. If so, we are interested as well, actually we would be very much interested in more background. Because there are still "white spots" on the genealogical map of the family of musicians. Plus, maybe we can help with our genealogical experience. Or there is a common interest to ask Christian Hoske for his help and we might finance this part together. Of course for a special low fee in addition. If you don't hear from us, if you get no answer to your mail, that's not our way to communicate, than your mail was blocked by our spam filter - please send your lines again, by snail mail, that is to say paper mail. We are looking forward to your feedback.
This was just it, not more than this single page, what my family considered a lost treasure in the volume of a shoe box for over 50 years. However, if you finally learned to cherish and to arrange this heritage, it's of priceless value. © Wikipedia.
Advertisement
1,000+ Bach Gifts in Five Bach Online Shops
Music gifts, music calendars … learn more.
60 Music Calendars, Composers Calendars and Bach Calendars
One of four composers postage stamps calendars and one of two Bach postage stamps calendars. Three sizes. This year and next year. EU style and US style. To the shop.
End of Advertisement